I find this problem in comics quite a bit as well, especially modern superhero stories.
If the characters aren’t invested in this story/conflict, then it’s much harder for the audience to be as well.
I’ve written sarcastic characters and characters who know the tropes they’re in the midst of. Doing that without losing the audience is tougher than you might think. The stakes must be clear, despite their quips or desire to be above the fray.
Emotional investment and sincerity is impressively resilient to changing trends in entertainment.
Don’t act like you’re too good for the genre you’re working in.
Don’t treat the past like your doormat.
You can be irreverent.
You can be sarcastic.
You can be critical.
But, beneath all that sass, there has to be knowledge and appreciation for the strengths and entertainment of the genre you’re riffing on or else it will feel hollow.
Your best friend gets to give you shit because, deep down, they also care and want the best for you.
Treat genre deconstruction the same way. Give ’em hell and make it hurt because you know which buttons to push that matter, not because you think you’re too cool for all of it.
Fantasy and magic are especially susceptible to this kind of abuse.
“It’s fantasy, so just make up a bunch of Chosen One/Destiny shit.”
“It’s magic, so nothing matters!”
Wrong.
You don’t understand the genre or why it has worldwide appeal.
0 Comments.